Takeoff and landing are the most critical
phases of flight. A study conducted by
Boeing revealed that 13% of all aircraft accidents happen during takeoff and
48% happen during landing (Boeing Commercial Airplanes, 2015) . These are significant figures that shed light
into the complexity of the operations, especially landing. Pilots are challenged to ensure landings are
safe in all conditions, whether day or night; the FAA clearly delineates that
the majority of the landing accidents are due to a failure in the decision
making process of the pilots (Federal Aviation Administration, 2008) . This is where technology, such as Autoland,
was developed to address the human factors and improve operational safety.
When
Boeing introduced the 787 Dreamliner, it was announced as the most
technologically advanced commercial passenger aircraft (Bender, 2013) .
It has even been described by pilots as “17 computer servers packaged in
a Kevlar frame” (Leff, 2012) . The aircraft is equipped with a modern array
of avionics systems and components. The
Honeywell powered flight control systems provide for automatic takeoff and
landings (Weisberger, 2012) . The aircraft utilizes data from the
Instrument Landing System (ILS) and GPS to ensure safety; pilots routinely use
components of the automatic takeoff and landing systems to augment manual
operations. “That being said, we do use
"pieces" of the autoflight system during takeoff. The auto-thrust
system is normally used to fine tune power after the pilot initiates takeoff,
the auto-brake system is set to RTO to react with brakes if the pilot closes
the thrust levers to Reject the TakeOff. Some pilots engage the autopilot above
a few hundred feet above ground, especially in busy terminal areas, so that the
pilots can manage the overall flight while they let the autopilot deal with the
details” (Inch, 2014) .
The
level of training provided to pilots who transition to the 787 varies of their
previous experience. A pilot with 777
flight experience can be 787 certified in as little as 5 days, while one with
non-Boeing experience must undergo 20 days of training (Nader, Al, Haber, & Reiter, 2008) . The training covers all areas of flight,
including Autoland. Maintenance
mechanics and engineers are also trained in the use of the Maintenance
Performance Toolbox system, which includes all aspects of avionics and systems (Boeing, 2012) . The level of training is a testament of the
complexity of the aircraft. A
recommendation to improve the automated takeoff and landing capabilities would
be to utilize the already integrated Ground Based Augmentation System (GBAS),
which will provide a lower cost and higher precision than ILS. The implementation of this approach is
currently pending approval by the FAA, but it is expected to take place in 2018
(Croft, 2015) .
An
unmanned system that performs automated takeoff and landing is the Falcon 9
rocket developed by SpaceX. The goal of
the company is to design and deploy a reusable rocket system to reduce the
overall cost of cargo movement to space (Space Exploration Technologies Corp, 2015) . The rocket utilizes a complex set of
maneuvers for launch and landing; after ascent and stage separation, the rocket
performs a maneuver and burn, followed by aerodynamic guidance by grid fins to
perform a vertical landing (Space Exploration Technologies Corp, 2015) . An important component of the landing feature
are the grid fins. “A key upgrade to
enable precision targeting of the Falcon 9 all the way to touchdown is the
addition of four hypersonic grid fins placed in an X-wing configuration around
the vehicle, stowed on ascent and deployed on reentry to control the stage’s
lift vector. Each fin moves independently for roll, pitch and yaw, and combined
with the engine gimbaling, will allow for precision landing – first on the
autonomous spaceport drone ship, and eventually on land” (Space Exploration Technologies Corp, 2014) .
Touchdown is performed by carbon fiber
landing legs that are automatically deployed before touchdown.
The
autonomous systems that provide for takeoff and landing have been further
refined since their introduction. The
company attempted a first landing on a barge that ultimately failed due to a
failure in one of the landing legs not fully deploying. “"Falcon lands on droneship, but the
lockout collet doesn't latch on one [of] the four legs, causing it to tip over
post-landing," Musk says. "[The] root cause may have been ice buildup
due to condensation from heavy fog at liftoff” (Grush, 2016) . This is an automated system that relies on
computational power for its successful operation. The complex nature of this system does not
provide for a manual operation, and it is not designed to be part of the system
Modern
aircraft, such as the 787, possess the necessary technology and equipment to
perform successful takeoffs and landing.
In the case of these aircraft it is the regulations that prevent full
system deployment in the interest of safety.
The FAA performs evaluations of newer technology and ensures there is
complete readiness before allowing automated operations. This is not the case for the Falcon 9 rocket;
it is designed to be unmanned and with a high level of autonomy. Automated landing and takeoff are integral
parts of the business approach from SpaceX, and their research investments are
paying off. The limitations of the
rocket are, for the most part, not regulatory but technology related. The future of transportation seems to move
into the direction of more autonomy, which will have the effect of reducing
costs and increasing safety.
References
Bender, A. (2013, January16). Airlines Ground 787
Dreamliner: Should Passengers Be Worried? Retrieved from Forbes.com:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/andrewbender /2013/01/16/airlines-ground-787-dreamliner-should-passengers-be-worried/#74ebeb04387f
Boeing. (2012). Maintenance
Performance Toolbox. Retrieved from Boeing.com:
http://www.boeing.com/resources/boeingdotcom/commercial/services/assets/brochure/maintenanceperformancetoolbox.pdf
Boeing Commercial Airplanes. (2015). Statistical
Summary of Commercial Jet Airplane Accidents. Retrieved from
http://www.boeing.com/resources/boeingdotcom/ company/about_bca/pdf/statsum.pdf
Croft, J. (2015, April 27). FAA
Targets 2018 For GPS-Based Autoland Capability. Retrieved from Aviation
Week Network: http://aviationweek.com/commercial-aviation/faa-targets-2018-gps-based-autoland-capability
Federal Aviation Administration.
(2008). On Landings III. Retrieved from FAASafety.gov:
https://www.faasafety.gov/files/gslac/library/documents/2011/Aug/56411/FAA%20P-8740-50%20OnLandingsPart%20III%20[hi-res]%20branded.pdf
Grush, L. (2016, January 17). SpaceX
fails a third time to land its Falcon 9 on a drone ship in the sea.
Retrieved from TheVerge.com: http://www.theverge.com/2016/1/17/ 10782708/spacex-launch-rocket-landing-failure-falcon-9
Inch, D. (2014, September 9). Why
can't planes take off and/or land using the auto-pilot feature? Retrieved
from Quora.com:
https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-planes-take-off-and-or-land-using-the-auto-pilot-feature
Leff, g. (2012, April 21). The
Boeing 787, for a Pilot's Perspective. Retrieved from
WiewfromtheWing.com:
http://viewfromthewing.boardingarea.com/2012/04/21/the-boeing-787-from-a-pilots-perspective/
Nader, Al, Haber, J., & Reiter, D.
(2008). 787 Training for pilots and mechanics. Retrieved from
Boeing.com: http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_1_08 /AERO_Q108_article2.pdf
Space Exploration Technologies Corp.
(2014, December 16). X MARKS THE SPOT: FALCON 9 ATTEMPTS OCEAN PLATFORM
LANDING. Retrieved from Spacex.com:
http://www.spacex.com/news/2014/12/16/x-marks-spot-falcon-9-attempts-ocean-platform-landing
Space Exploration Technologies Corp.
(2015, June 25). The Why and How of Landing Rockets. Retrieved from
http://www.spacex.com/news/2015/06/24/why-and-how-landing-rockets
Weisberger, H. (2012, July 11). Honeywell
Takes Systems Integration To A New Level On 787. Retrieved from
AINOnline.com:
http://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/farnborough-air-show/2012-07-11/honeywell-takes-systems-integration-new-level-787
Post a Comment